Case #050E – Goberdhan v. Knights of Columbus

ONTARIO – Where there was no consideration for a contract containing a mandatory arbitration clause, the Court exercised its discretion to refuse to stay the action under s. 7(2) the Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c.17 on the basis that the arbitration clause was invalid. Section 7(1) of the Act applies to cases where the interpretation of the arbitration clause is at issue, not where the clause’s very existence is questioned.

Continue reading

Case #049E – Dufferin v. Morrison Hershfield

ONTARIO – Application to remove a sole arbitrator of a complex construction dispute due to alleged apprehension of bias dismissed. The Arbitrator was selected for his construction expertise and was permitted to question witnesses and ask questions at any time during the hearing under a procedural order. The arbitrator’s interventions, unlike interventions by a trial judge, were not evidence of bias.

Continue reading

Case #048E – Force One Marketing et al. v. Rritual Superfoods

ONTARIO – Forum Non Conveniens -The Ontario Court had jurisdiction to hear a contract dispute on the basis that the Ontario Court has jurisdiction simpliciter over the subject-matter of the contract, even though the defendant did not have a substantial connection with Ontario. A BC forum selection clause in a related agreement was not binding on the plaintiff. The defendant failed to prove that Ontario was not the forum conveniens to hear the dispute.

Continue reading